Mamdani says his Israel stance is core to ‘Trump-proofing’ NYC

Plus, Jews in NY State are twice as likely as voters overall to hold an unfavorable view of Mamdani

Zohran Mamdani meets supporters at the Flatbush Gardens housing complex in Brooklyn on 12 August, 2025. (Screenshot from X)

Upstate upset:
A Siena Institute poll found that while Zohran Mamdani gains popularity in New York City, voters outside the Big Apple have a negative opinion of him — especially Jews.

Across the state, 75 percent of Jews reported an unfavourable opinion of Mamdani, a much greater share than 37 percent of voters overall. A similar share of overall voters, 34 percent, said they did not know of Mamdani or had no opinion, while 28 percent viewed him favourably.

Surveyed Jews did not particularly like the other candidates, either — 61 percent had a negative view of Mayor Eric Adams, 54 percent said the same of Gov. Andrew Cuomo and 38 percent said the same of Republican nominee Curtis Sliwa.

A narrower focus on New York City showed Mamdani leading the race by 19 points, similar to his performance in other recent polls. But this poll diverged from others that showed Mamdani also leading among Jewish voters. Instead, Siena pollsters reported 44 percent of Jewish New Yorkers said they would vote for Cuomo, followed by 23 percent for Sliwa and 20 percent  for Mamdani.

The pollsters cautioned their NYC sample was small, with a 6.7 percent margin of error that increased for subgroups. They noted that “some results should be taken as anecdotal.”

Mamdani says his Israel stance is core to “Trump-proofing” NYC:          In an interview with The Nation published on Tuesday, Mamdani said his stance on Israel was part of his plan to “Trump-proof” the city. He is currently making his way through a “Five Boroughs Against Trump” tour of New York, centring the president in his bid to win the general election.

Along with protecting the city from federal budget cuts and enforcing New York’s sanctuary-city policies, Mamdani said he would fight Trump’s agenda by being a voice for New Yorkers “living through despair,” whether over the cost of living or over “watching in anguish as their tax dollars are used to kill civilians in Gaza.”

Mamdani was also asked about his resistance to changing his language on issues from Israel to taxing the wealthy. “If I’ve made policy commitments, I’ve made them because I intend to keep them,” he said. “I want to be honest about them. That doesn’t stop me from continuing to learn how to be a leader for this entire city.”

A Brooklyn stop without key Dems:                                                  Mamdani continued his tour against Trump at the Flatbush Gardens housing complex on Tuesday. He was joined by a group of Democrats ranging from moderates to progressives and democratic socialists — but a few key party and Brooklyn leaders were not in attendance.

Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries and Rep. Yvette Clarke, prominent Democrats who have not endorsed Mamdani, were not there.

Endorsement tracker:
Former Gov. David Paterson is endorsing Adams today. He endorsed Cuomo in the primary and since has called on candidates to commit to coalescing around a single opponent to Mamdani. Paterson, who led the state from 2008 to 2010, has long had strong relationships with Jewish groups and communities.

Paterson’s flip-flop indicates that Cuomo is struggling to retain those who endorsed him in the primary. Several Jewish primary backers recently told us they hadn’t yet decided whom to back in the general election.

read more:
comments