Auschwitz Museum defends blocking Israel flags at Birkenau

Museum says flag procession was not pre-approved, but IDF delegation calls the blockage antisemitic and deeply disrespectful

Young Jews from around the world walk with Israeli flags through the former Nazi German death camp of Auschwitz-Birkenau during the annual Holocaust remembrance event, the "March of the Living" in memory of the six million Holocaust victims in Oswiecim, Poland, Thursday, May 2, 2019.(AP Photo/Czarek Sokolowski)
Young Jews from around the world walk with Israeli flags through the former Nazi German death camp of Auschwitz-Birkenau during the annual Holocaust remembrance event, the "March of the Living" in memory of the six million Holocaust victims in Oswiecim, Poland, Thursday, May 2, 2019.(AP Photo/Czarek Sokolowski)

The Auschwitz-Birkenau Museum has defended its decision to block an Israeli military delegation from carrying national flags into the former Nazi death camp during a Holocaust education visit last week.

Israeli officers taking part in the IDF’s Witnesses in Uniform programme were stopped at the entrance to Birkenau and ordered to remove their flags before proceeding. The delegation of 180 soldiers and security officials had prepared for the ceremony with military trumpets and a flag procession, as in previous years.

Participants described the incident as tense and humiliating. One officer told Ynet that it was a painful reminder that “we are still fighting antisemitism in Europe” and accused authorities of trying to “change the Zionist narrative and the sanctity of this place for us”.

While some initially believed the order came from local police, the museum later stated that the intervention had been made by its own staff in accordance with longstanding procedures. It said the organisers had only sought approval for a closing ceremony at the monument and had failed to inform the museum of any flag-bearing procession in advance.

In a statement, the museum said the rules were designed to safeguard the dignity and neutrality of the site and prevent any group from politicising the grounds. “Approximately 1.1 million people were murdered here, primarily Jews,” it said. “Special safeguards exist due to past attempts to misuse this historical site.”

The museum added that prior approval would have been granted had the correct request been made. It called on future delegations to coordinate plans in advance to avoid what it described as an “entirely avoidable” outcome.

This is not the first time Israeli flags have sparked controversy at the site. In February, British Jewish tourists from Bushey Synagogue were told to hand over Israeli flags bearing yellow hostage ribbons during a memorial visit. Auschwitz staff later defended the move, saying any alteration to a national flag, including the addition of symbols, violates the museum’s rules. The flags were returned at the end of the tour.

read more: